That Certain Feeling — Sheri Cobb South

To pass her initiation into Pressler High's most exclusive sorority Penny Collier must steal a rival school's basketball playbook. Thought she's not crazy about the idea, she is crazy about basketball star Brandon Phillips.

Hoping to impress Brandon, she agrees to filch the playbook from her friend Woody, a member of the rival team. Though she feels guilty, Penny convinces herself that it's just a harmless prank. But as she gets to know Woody better, Penny realizes that she's falling in love with him. How can she bring herself to steal from the boy who has stolen her heart?