That Other Girl — Conrad Nowels

Donna is older, carefree, and so beautiful, but she is going off to college and plans to date other guys. Larry thinks he'll never stop loving her, until he meets Judy. Shy and sweet, she can't compete with Donna, but she captures Larry's wounded heart.

Then Donna returns and makes it very clear she wants Larry back. Suddenly, he isn't so sure he's over Donna at all…and all three of them are caught in a crazy love triangle.