A romantic fall buggy ride is the perfect setting for love.
Janie Lantz works as a cashier at the Lancaster Souvenirs and Buggy Rides tourist attraction in Bird-in-Hand, where Jonathan Stoltfuz is a buggy driver. One day Janie witnesses Jonathan's buggy getting rear-ended and a few people are injured. Jonathan feels terrible about the accident and blames himself, and even though it wasn't his fault, his boss won't let him drive a buggy anymore. Since Janie witnessed the accident, she is able to clear Jonathan's name, and his appreciation of her grows along with their friendship. But Janie's parents have reservations about her dating someone older who has a dangerous job. Will they see that he is the young man for her, or will the coming winter end Jonathan's job and any hope of love?