Four years ago, Keith Travers turned his back on God and his family to pursue a secular music career. But despite the fame and fortune, years of wild living have left Keith feeling empty. When he learns the winner of a "dream date with Keith Travers" contest lives near his hometown, Keith uncharacteristically makes the trip to meet with the woman, while secretly intending to visit his family.
When he arrives, Keith finds a woman, Shae Stevens, who has no interest in a date with him and has never even heard him sing. Intrigued, he sets out to unravel the mystery of why this woman, blessed with a beautiful voice, bolts from the room when he invites her to become one of his backup singers.
Shae has her hands full raising a fourteen-year-old sister, Tiffany, while running the Rhode Island inn they inherited from their grandmother. Tiffany's latest escapade was secretly entering Shae in the magazine contest that resulted in her "date" with Keith Travers. When Keith and his manager turn up at the inn to meet their winner, Shae tries desperately to avoid them. Would the publicity expose her true identity and the terrible secret she has guarded for seven long years?