Two-timing Aisha — Katherine Applegate

Two-timing Aisha doesn't like playing games with the two guys she loves. But how can she decide between Christopher, her longtime boyfriend, and brilliant but maddening David? Breaking up with either of them seems impossible, but keeping them both could be even harder.
They've all grown up together on a tiny island. They think they know everything about one another . . . but they're only just beginning to find out the truth.